Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
MaddowBlog-Gaslighting on gas prices: Trump points to 'very substantial' drop that didn't happen
Consumers know that gas prices aren’t “way down.” So why is the president trying to fool them into believing otherwise?
There’s a difference between lies and self-defeating lies.
— Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2026-05-08T14:01:28.413Z
When Trump points to a “very substantial†drop in gas prices, and says prices at the pump are “way down,†consumers know better for the most obvious of reasons: their own life experiences.
www.ms.now/rachel-maddo...
https://www.ms.now/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/gaslighting-on-gas-prices-trump-points-to-very-substantial-drop-that-didnt-happen
During an unexpected Q&A with reporters on Thursday afternoon, Donald Trump was asked about whether he was prepared to shift his tactics in the Middle East “now that gas prices are more than $4.50” per gallon. The president challenged the premise of the question.
.....In this reality, the evidence shows otherwise. According to AAA’s latest tally, gas prices actually inched higher on Thursday, reaching $4.56 a gallon, before easing by one penny, to $4.55, as Friday got underway.
A week ago, the average was $4.39 a gallon. A month ago, it was $4.16 a gallon. There’s been no “very substantial” drop, and gas prices are by no means “way down.” Energy policy can be complex, but this is pretty simple stuff.
Stepping back, it’s genuinely bizarre to see so many prominent Republicans peddle such brazen falsehoods. Last week, it was House Majority Leader Steve Scalise declaring on CNBC that consumers are paying $3 per gallon, which wasn’t even close to being true. Around the same time, Republican Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina appeared on Fox Business and told viewers, “Gas prices continue to come down,” even as gas prices continued to go up.
This week, it was Trump trying his hand at gaslighting on gas prices.
But while prominent GOP leaders’ casual indifference to the truth might seem unremarkable, and “Trump says untrue thing” isn’t exactly an unusual revelation, what continues to amaze me about this specific line of argument is how neatly it dovetails with Trump’s lies about grocery prices.....
If Trump and his allies want to argue that rising prices aren’t his fault, they’re welcome to give it a try. If they want to claim that conditions will soon improve, some people might believe them.
But to tell consumers not to believe their own lying eyes about their own wallets is a recipe for failure.
Q: Are you considering going back to Project Freedom now that gas prices are more than .50?
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) 2026-05-08T00:51:24.481Z
TRUMP: No. Gas prices have come down today. Have you looked? They came down very substantially today. The stock market is way up.
.....In this reality, the evidence shows otherwise. According to AAA’s latest tally, gas prices actually inched higher on Thursday, reaching $4.56 a gallon, before easing by one penny, to $4.55, as Friday got underway.
A week ago, the average was $4.39 a gallon. A month ago, it was $4.16 a gallon. There’s been no “very substantial” drop, and gas prices are by no means “way down.” Energy policy can be complex, but this is pretty simple stuff.
Stepping back, it’s genuinely bizarre to see so many prominent Republicans peddle such brazen falsehoods. Last week, it was House Majority Leader Steve Scalise declaring on CNBC that consumers are paying $3 per gallon, which wasn’t even close to being true. Around the same time, Republican Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina appeared on Fox Business and told viewers, “Gas prices continue to come down,” even as gas prices continued to go up.
This week, it was Trump trying his hand at gaslighting on gas prices.
But while prominent GOP leaders’ casual indifference to the truth might seem unremarkable, and “Trump says untrue thing” isn’t exactly an unusual revelation, what continues to amaze me about this specific line of argument is how neatly it dovetails with Trump’s lies about grocery prices.....
If Trump and his allies want to argue that rising prices aren’t his fault, they’re welcome to give it a try. If they want to claim that conditions will soon improve, some people might believe them.
But to tell consumers not to believe their own lying eyes about their own wallets is a recipe for failure.